You’ve Been a Good Old Wagon But You’ve Done Broke Down
Benjamin Robertson “Ben” Harney (6 March 1872 – 2 March 1938) was a songwriter, entertainer, and pioneer of ragtime music. His 1895 composition “You’ve Been a Good Old Wagon but You Done Broke Down” is regarded as one of the first published ragtime songs. In 1924, the New York Times wrote that Ben Harney “probably did more to popularize ragtime than any other person.” Time Magazine termed him “Ragtime’s Father” in 1938. — from the Wikipedia profile of Ben Harney
You’ve Been a Good Old Wagon But You Done Broke Down (Harney & Biller) — Ben Harney and John Biller
Ben Harney sings a cappella, in a performance recorded by the archivist Robert Winslow Gordon, possibly in 1925* (Gordon Cylinder G24)
(above) The style of Harney’s song in the Gordon recording does not seem to exemplify ragtime. In this recording, reportedly the only existent one of “The Father of Ragtime” performing, Harney sings a folk song, in a simple “country” style. Which folk song? Read on…
(below) Jamie Levac plays solo on an 1869 square grand piano made in London, Ontario. Well done. But I would like to ask Mr. Levac why that’s not “Frog Went A-Courtin’.” The same question must be asked of Harney’s recording.
Comments by doc, amended on 28 November 2013:
With regard to my speculation, above, as to the origin of Harney’s Good Old Wagon, and to comments by the visitor to the Songbook page 1890-1899 Selected hits and standards, Mike Mason, who points out (Aug 08, 2010 @ 10:56:03) that it is a variant of two related folk songs, “Sugar Babe” and “Crawdad Hole,” I’ll respond by referring to a couple of sources. First, from an article on a page of the Library of Congress website (loc.gov), under the title Folk-Songs of America: The Robert Winslow Gordon Collection, 1922-1932:
The tune [Good Old Wagon] is similar to that of “The Crawdad Song,” and almost all the verses can be found in standard folksong collections. For instance, a single collection—Volume III of the Frank C. Brown omnibus from North Carolina—contains at least four songs which have elements of either verse or structure which parallel “The Wagon”: “The Dummy Line” (p. 521), “Sugar Babe” (p. 550), and “Went Down Town” and “Standin’ On The Street Doin’ No Harm” (p. 562). Of course, because Harney published his text in 1895 and performed it frequently for the next thirty years, it is quite possible that at least some of the texts recorded by folksong collectors during the early decades of this century reflect the popularity of Harney’s song.
Second, in an article in the journal American Music, in Volume 13, No. 2 (Summer 1995), titled “Ben Harney: The Middlesborough Years, 1890-93,” by William H. Tallmadge (p. 167ff.), on pages 180-181 the author points out African-American folk blues (“common in the Appalachian Mountains”) sources of Harney’s “Good Old Wagon,” noting similarities to “Sugar Babe,” “Sweet Thing,” and “Crawdad Song,” and quotes John and Alan Lomax on the adoption of the Negro blues “Sweet Thing” by white banjo and guitar pickers to the extent that “today it can be heard wherever a hillbilly unlimbers his git-box” (p. 181).
Tallmadge agrees with the Lomaxes regarding the influence of “Sweet Thing,” but concludes (p. 181) that “the basic folk tune common to the many variants, both black and white, derived from the much earlier British folk song A Frog He Went a-Courting.”
“Frog Went a-Courtin'” links:
The opinion of the distinguished professor emeritus of the State University of New York in Buffalo, William H. Tallmadge, may have been shaped by years of study in American folk music history. For me, the recognition of a song I first heard and learned when I was knee-high to a crawdad was instantaneous. Perhaps two or three bars into the video of Jamie Levac performing what he says is Harney & Biller’s “You’ve Been a Good Old Wagon,” I thought, “Wait a minute. That’s obviously “Frog Went a-Courtin’.” There’s been some mistake.”
Despite what seems to be a very obvious connection between “Frog Went a-Courtin’,” and “You’ve Been a Good Old Wagon,” Jane Keefer’s comprehensive catalog of folk music, Folk Music Index to Recordings, disagrees. The index lists 15 related titles and 7 related melodies for “Crawdad,” and 9 related titles (not minor spelling variants) for “Frog/Froggie Went A-Courting,” yet, according to Ms. Keefer, they have no related titles or melodies in common.** 1940s Asch recordings of “Crawdad” and “Froggie Went a-Courtin'” by Woody Guthrie*** (videos included in the footnote) sound like recordings of essentially the same song, the principle difference, apart from the dissimilar lyrics, lying in the respective tempos at which they are played.
The Harney & Biller Good Old Wagon lyric as provided by Joe Offer in a Mudcat Café thread:
I was standing in a crap game doing no harm, baby!
When a copper grabbed me by my arm, honey!
Took me down to the jailhouse door,
Place I never had been before, I was run in.
No more will I buy my sweet thing pork chops!
And hear her lily lips go flip flop!
The reason I’m in trouble ’bout my sweet thing
Is because this song to me she did sing:
“Goodbye, my honey, if you call it gone, darling!
Goodbye, my honey, if you call it gone, baby!
Goodbye, my honey, if you call it gone,
You’ve been a good old wagon but you done broke down; bye-bye.”
The judge asked me what had I done; baby!
Said standing in a crap game getting my gun, hot stuff!
The judge and jury said to me,
“You have killed three people in the first degree; no bail.”
The lyric provided by Joe Offer at Mudcat Café corresponds virtually exactly, the only differences being in capitalization and punctuation, to one found in a set of sheet music pages available at the New York Public Library Digital Gallery, here:
- “Good Old Wagon”, Harney & Biller (1895) NYPL Digital Gallery, 4 pages (front and back covers missing)
A transcription of the lyric sung by Harney in the Gordon recording has been published in the article at the Library of Congress website (loc.gov) cited above, under the title
Variants of some of the lines in the lyric of the 1895 sheet music are sung by Harney in the Gordon recording. The last line of the final two sections of Gordon’s recording of Harney performing “Good Old Wagon,” which goes “A-this mornin’, this evenin’, so soon,” suggests its connection, lyrically, to the traditional songs “This Morning, This Evening, So Soon” and “Tell Old Bill.” A recording of the latter by the Kingston Trio was released under the title “This Mornin’, This Evenin’, So Soon” on their 1960 album String Along.
Raymond’s Folk Song Page, says of “Crawdad” and related songs:
This song from the Southern States of the U.S. grew out of African-American blues combined with white American children’s play songs. There are a number of variations, such as This Morning, This Evening, So Soon, Sweet Thing, How Many Biscuits Can You Eat? and What Ya Gonna Do?, as sung by Josh White, for example.
The aforementioned William H. Tallmadge article, “Ben Harney: The Middlesborough Years, 1890-93,” is my source of the sheet music cover (see above, top) which credits “Harney & Biller” as the songwriters, and features an illustration of the two. “Good Old Wagon” is a major focal point of the piece. There are pages devoted to the song’s possible folk roots, to it’s relationships with specific folk blues songs of the Appalachian Mountains, and to an appended stop-time stick dance created and performed by Harney which the author finds particularly noteworthy.
(above) from the article “Ben Harney: The Middlesborough Years, 1890-93,” by William H. Tallmadge, in the journal American Music, Volume 13, No. 2 (Summer 1995), p. 174
On pages 173-174 the author describes the process of getting Harney’s song, which he had brought with him “in his head and in his fingers” when he went to Louisville in 1893, onto paper. The account is supplemented with speculation by the author as to the extent of Biller’s contribution. Tallmadge suggests that Biller’s name may have been added because he was a well-known musician, and perhaps also in return for helping to get it published sooner. Biller was hired by the publisher, Bruner Greenup (of Greenup Music Company of Louisville Kentucky) to transcribe what Harney played and sang. Tallmadge quotes an 1899 interview with Greenup:
Harney had no more idea than a monkey how to write rag time, though he could play it and sing it, perhaps, better than anyone has yet succeeded in doing…
Greenup goes on to explain that numerous “more or less famous” composers were called in to work on the task of getting Harney’s tune on paper, yet one by one they gave up in frustration, reporting that the job was too difficult. John Biller was the musical director for Macauley’s Theatre, the premier theatre, according to Wikipedia, in Louisville during the late 19th and early 20th century. Finally, they took the song to Biller who, after perhaps 500 playings (Greenup’s estimate) by Harney was able to get the song on paper sometime in 1893.
I haven’t read the entire piece yet, which might provide some explanation, but it strikes me as rather odd that after such a great expenditure of effort to get the song on paper it was not published by Greenup until over a year later, in 1895. I wonder, also, if and how the author reconciles the claims that Harney had no clue as to how to transcribe ragtime, and that numerous “more or less famous” composers failed in their attempts to accomplish the task in this case, with the opinion that Biller’s contribution might have been negligible, if the music was indeed written down in 1893 by none other than Biller. The inference is that Biller might, or might not, have merely recorded note for note what he heard Harney play, with every dynamic modulation, articulation, ornament, etc. precisely rendered into musical notation.
According to some biographies of Ben Harney, the style in which he wrote led many contemporaries to believe he was a black man. The error was still being repeated decades after his death. In a post within the blog Locust St., titled Elite Syncopations, 1900-1901, while commenting upon a cylinder recording of the Good Old Wagon by Len Spencer, the author notes that even Eubie Blake was certain that Harney was black, and that he evidently convinced Alec Wilder of the same:
The story circles inward, like the whorls of a seashell. “You’ve Been a Good Old Wagon”‘s composer, ragtime pioneer Benjamin Harney, was thought to be black by many of his contemporaries. The pianist Eubie Blake, interviewed by Alec Wilder in the early ’70s, said of Harney, “He’s dead, and all of his people must be. Do you know that Ben Harney was a Negro?” Convinced, Wilder, in his American Popular Song, calls Harney “one of the best Negro writers of the late nineteenth century.” The Harney family, on its genealogical website, makes an exhausting case, however, that Harney was a white man born to white parents.
* Regarding the date of the recording of Ben Harney singing Good Old Wagon, made by Robert Winslow Gordon, the aforementioned Library of Congress article says,
It is not known when or where Gordon recorded him, but an indistinct announcement on one of the five cylinders which he made seems to place the session on September 9, 1925, about a month before Gordon’s first North Carolina recordings of Lewey and Noell.
The blues song “You’ve Been a Good Ole Wagon” first recorded by Bessie Smith in 1925 (Columbia 14079-D, c/w “Dixie Flyer Blues”) is an unrelated number, with a different history. I mention this because a lot of folks are confusing them on the internet. Some are up at arms that Harney is not credited for the unrelated Smith song. If there’s any relationship between the music or lyric of Harney’s newfangled 1890s twist on “Frog Went a-Courtin’,” probably via “The Crawdad Song” and other American folk blues songs, as noted above, and the Bessie Smith song, I haven’t seen or heard it.
There is disagreement as to who wrote Smith’s “Good Old Wagon.” The song was in Dave Van Ronk’s repertoire and he believed it was written by Clarence Williams for Smith. In an interview he recounts how it was composed by Williams to fill a request by Okeh records for a song with commercial appeal similar to the enormously popular “Crazy Blues” of 1920. However, redhotjazz.com credits “Smith/Balcom” (Bessie Smith and Stuart Balcom) as the songwriters of Smith’s “Good Old Wagon”.
** Links to selected titles in Jane Keefer’s Folk Music Index to Recordings:
- Frog Went A-Courting
- Crawdad Song
- Sweet Thing
- This Morning, This Evening, So Soon – I — No author given. Listed as related to “Wagon” (Ben Harney), as well as to Crawdad (Song), and Policeman #1
- Wagon — That’s the full title given by Keefer, not “You’ve Been a Good Old Wagon But You Done Broke Down” or anything like. Keefer credits only one songwriter, Ben Harney. According to Keefer, “This Morning, This Evening, So Soon” is related to “Wagon,” and both are related to “Crawdad.”
- key to abbreviations
*** Woodie Guthrie recordings of “Froggie Went a-Courtin'” and “Crawdad Song”:
musicians for the sessions (from http://www.woodyguthrie.de/discog3.html):
- Woody Guthrie (vocals, guitar, fiddle, mandolin, harmonica)
- Cisco Houston (vocals, guitar)
- Bess Lomax Hawes (mandolin)
- Sonny Terry (harmonica)
- Leadbelly (vocals, guitar) on “Stewball” (Version 2)
musicians for the sessions:
- Woody Guthrie (vocals, guitar, mandolin, fiddle)
- Cisco Houston (vocals, guitar)
- Butch Hawes (guitar)
- Bess Lomax Hawes (mandolin, background vocals)
- Pete Seeger (banjo)
- Sonny Terry (harmonica)
- lyric (transcribed by doc, 30 Nov 2013)
Of “Crawdad Song,” SecondHandSongs.com says:
Folksong originating in the southern United States and first published in a collection of songs in 1917 by Cecil Sharp. This song is apparently a variation of an older traditional work, “Sweet Thing”, which is of African-American origins. “Crawdad Song” is collected as number 4853 in the Roud Folksong Index.
- See my page Crawdad Song — selected recordings, 1933-1967 (link fixed on 29 September 2016) for additional recordings of “Crawdad Song,” aka “The Crawdad Song,” “Crawdad Hole,” Crawdad,” “You Get a Line and I’ll Get a Pole,” etc. SecondHandSongs.com identifies an October 1929 recording by Honeyboy & Sassafras as the first recording of the song. However, I haven’t included recordings of the song made prior to 1933 in the page, under any of the aforementioned titles, because I haven’t yet found any. My “Crawdad Song” page includes recordings of the song under various titles by the following artists:
- Lone Star Cowboys — recorded on 5 August 1933
- Jim Lewis Lonestar Cowboys — recorded on 24 September 1937
- Leroy Martin and unidentified performers (vocals) — recorded on 21 May 1939
- Mrs. Vernon Allen — recorded on 16 August 1940
- Woodie Guthrie — recorded between 1944 and 1947
- Al Clauser and his Oklahoma Outlaws — 1947(?)
- Lulu Belle & Scotty — c.1950
- Evelyn Knight and Red Foley — recorded on 28 November 1950
- Smokey Hogg — recorded on 9 January 1952
- Big Bill Broonzy — four recordings, three of them variously dated within the span 1953-1957, the other undated
- Sam Hinton — released in 1957
- The Goldenaires Choir — released in 1959
- Brownie McGhee and Sonny Terry — recorded in 1961; released in 1978
- Flatt & Scruggs with the Foggy Mountain Boys — television performance, broadcast in 1962
- Doc Watson, Clint Howard, and Fred Price — recorded in April 1962
- Doc Watson, Clint Howard, and Fred Price — recorded in 1967
Selected recordings of some related songs
Whatcha Gonna Do When Your Licker Gives Out?
Fiddlin’ John Carson — possibly from the 17 December 1929 recording issued on the 10″ 78 rpm single Okeh 45434, as the B-side of “Sunny Tennessee”
BluegrassMessengers.com, in its pages on each of eleven different versions of “Sugar Babe” (e.g. Version 1: Sharp, 1917) in its collection of fiddle tune lyrics, includes the following titles among it’s list of related songs:
“Baby Mine,” “Crawdad (Song),” “New River Train,” “I’m Going Back to Jericho (Mexico),” “This Morning, This Evening, So Soon,” “Policeman,” “Ain’t No Use in Working So Hard,” “How Many Biscuits Can You Eat,” “Going round the World Baby Mine/Banjo Pickin’ Girl,” “Gambler’s Song,” “Sweet Child,” “What You Gonna Do?” “Sweet Thing,” “Good Times,” “Crow-Fish Man,” “Honey Babe,” “Pittsburgh Town,” “Pittsburgh,” “Susie,” “Alice Brown”
From the “Notes” section of each “Sugar Babe” version page at BluegrassMessengers.com (bold added):
The song, Sugar Babe, is closely related to “Crawdad Song” (You get a line I’ll get a pole). The first printed version is a popular song “Baby Mine” from the late 1800’s. The song form used in “Baby Mine” published in 1874 as “Baby Mine” with words by Charles Mackay and music by Achibald Johnson is similar to the Captain Kidd/Froggy Went A-Courtin’ family of songs.
Lulu Belle & Scotty — 1935
The video provider attaches the following informaton:
** 1st Recording Session**… Recorded 30 October 1935 Furniture Mart Building, 666 Lake Shore Drive, Chicago, IL — Lulu Belle Wiseman [vcl], Scotty Wiseman [vcl/gt/banjo] …MYRTLE ELEANOR COOPER (From Boone NC 1913 – 1999)…And…SCOTT GREENE WISEMAN (From Ingalls NC 1909 – 1981)…Married in 1934…Very Popular & Famous Duo From 1934 to 1958…”Scotty” Wrote The Famous Country Classic “Have I Told You Lately That I Love You”
Sugar Babe — field recordings, 1939
John Lowry Goree (vocals) — recorded at his home in Houston, Texas, on 12 April 1939, by John and Ruby Lomax
Sims Tartt, Mandy Tartt, Bettie Atmore (vocals with tapping) — recorded on the porch of the home of Mr. & Mrs. W.P. Tartt, Livingston, Alabama, on 30 May 1939, by John Lomax
How Many Biscuits Can You Eat
Coon Creek Girls — broadcast date (TV) and other info to be provided ASAP
Merle Haggard performs a relative of “Frog Went a-Courtin'” and “Crawdad,” possibly titled “This Morning, This Evening, So Soon” (date and location unknown) — It’s difficult to make out some of the words. The repeated phrase in the first section seems to be “Picked my cotton in a ten yard sack.” In the second section, unless my ears deceive me, Haggard seems to be repeatedly referring to someone called “Old Aint [Aunt] James.”
Keyword searches combining the title “This Morning, This Evening, So Soon” and “lyric” typically point to the lyric of the traditional song “Tell Old Bill,” which has “This Morning, This Evening, So Soon,” and similar variants, as an alternate title, and which includes that phrase in its lyric. However, all versions of “Tell Old Bill” that I’ve heard (Dave Van Ronk, Kingston Trio, Chad Mitchell Trio, for example), are quite different melodically and rhythmically than any versions of “Frog” or “Crawdad” that I’m aware of, and unlike the song performed here by Merle Haggard, although the basic structure is similar.
None of my searches have uncovered a lyric resembling the one sung by Haggard in this performance except with respect to the phrase “This Morning, This Evening, So Soon,” though the repeated lines “Yonder comes a [feller/man/”n” word, etc.] with a sack on his back” from “Crawdad Song” — as performed by Jim Lewis Lonestar Cowboys (1937), Sam Hinton (1957), Flatt & Scruggs with the Foggy Mountain Boys (1962) and others — and “Picked my cotton in a ten yard sack” (Haggard) share a significant word. With regard to “Old Aint James,” see the reference to the alternate lyric line beginning with the similar “Old Aunt Jemima” in the “Description” of the “Back to Jericho” digital entry at fresnostate.edu (from the California State University, Fresno, digital Traditional Ballads Index). The same “description” is given in a slightly modified form in the Notes section of BluegrassMessengers.com’s “Back to Jericho,” and “I’m Goin’ Back to Jericho” pages.
As on any Songbook page or post, comments may be added below. See relevant comments in the Songbook survey page “1890-1899 selected hits and standards,“ which were posted before this page was created and the “You’ve Been a Good Old Wagon But You’ve Done Broke Down” feature was relocated from that page to this one. WordPress.com does not, to my knowledge, allow transfer of comments from one page or post to another.